Macon Telegraph | 11/10/2005 | Leak raises disturbing questions
Macon Telegraph | 11/10/2005 | Leak raises disturbing questions
This is a most interesting editorial.
The Telegraph on one hand supports the need for “secrecy” while also supporting a shield law that would prevent irresponsible journalists from being punished for leaking these secrets. It seems to me that the freedom of the press needs sane limitations much like freedom of speech and the right to keep and bear arms.
Freedom of speech is limited by the time, place and manner doctrine and the right to keep and bear arms is limited by state laws in much the same fashion with limits on the places and ways arms can be borne.
There can be little legitimate argument in favor of granting to the news media an unlimited right to publish government secrets that harm national security. There is a need for balance in this area and the courts are the proper venue for these questions to be raised.
Let journalists publish what they will but when they cross the line and give comfort to the leakers who seek to advance personal agendas force them to reveal the sources of the leaks so that the leakers can face the harsh light of justice for the damage they cause.
See also an editorial from October 5th 2005 :
Macon Telegraph - October 5, 2005 - 10 A
A SOLID REASON FOR SHIELD LAWS